Substance use as a public health issue: A critical review of the Canadian literature, 1896–2020

Lit review
by
Crépault, Jean-François et al.

Release Date

2024

Geography

Canada

Language of Resource

English

Full Text Available

No

Open Access / OK to Reproduce

No

Peer Reviewed

Yes

Objective

This study sought to trace the historical development and evolution of the concept of a public health approach to substance use in Canada through a critical review of the academic literature.

Findings/Key points

Overall we found a gradual convergence towards a potential Canadian model for a public health approach to substance use: a model based on principles including human rights and equity, in which psychoactive substances are neither criminalized nor commercialized, but rather strictly regulated, proportionately to the risks they pose, in a manner that optimizes the health of the population. At present, governments across Canada appear to be moving in the opposite direction.

Design/methods

Critical review is a method designed to systematically search a body of literature, take stock of its evolution and current state, identify conceptual contributions, and compare schools of thought. Systematic searches were conducted in February and March 2023 in five English-language databases and three French-language databases. Eligible articles were written in English or French by a first author based in Canada, focused primarily on substance use, and published in 2020 or earlier. 64 articles, published between 1896 and 2020, were synthesized.

Keywords

Advocacy
Illegal drugs
Policy/Regulatory
Decriminalization/legalization
Legal system/law enforcement